Lamar Jackson Vs. Josh Allen: Who To Draft?

by Jhon Lennon 44 views

Hey fantasy football fanatics! If you're like me, you're already itching for the season to start and diving deep into those crucial draft decisions. One of the biggest debates this year is: Lamar Jackson or Josh Allen? Both quarterbacks are absolute studs, capable of winning you weeks with their arms and legs. But who should you prioritize in your fantasy draft? Let's break it down, shall we?

The Case for Lamar Jackson

When we talk about Lamar Jackson, we're talking about a true game-changer. His 2019 MVP season is etched in fantasy football history, and for good reason. The dude is a human cheat code when he's at his best. Here's why you might want to snag Lamar:

  • Rushing Upside: Okay, this is the big one. Lamar isn't just a quarterback who can run; he's a running back playing quarterback. He's got the potential to give you 700-1000 rushing yards and a handful of rushing touchdowns every single year. That's insane! This rushing ability gives him a floor that very few quarterbacks can match. Even if his passing numbers are down in a particular game, he can still salvage your fantasy day with his legs. This is especially valuable in leagues that reward rushing yards heavily or give points per carry.

  • High Ceiling: When Lamar is on, he's on. We've seen him put up video game numbers, throwing for 300+ yards and rushing for another 100+ in the same game. That kind of upside is rare, and it can win you your week single-handedly. Imagine your opponent's face when Lamar drops 40+ fantasy points on them out of nowhere. Pure gold!

  • Offensive Scheme: With the Ravens' commitment to a run-heavy offense, Lamar is always a threat to take off. The offensive line is built to create running lanes, and the play-calling often features designed quarterback runs. This system is tailor-made for Lamar's skillset, and it maximizes his fantasy potential.

  • Proven Track Record: Lamar has already proven he can be the overall QB1 in fantasy football. He's done it before, and he has the talent and opportunity to do it again. That kind of track record is reassuring, especially when you're investing a high draft pick in a quarterback.

However, it's not all sunshine and rainbows with Lamar. Injuries have been a concern in recent years, and his passing numbers haven't always been consistent. But when he's healthy and clicking, he's an unstoppable force. Plus, with the addition of new receiving threats, his passing game could be in for a boost this year.

The Case for Josh Allen

Now, let's talk about Josh Allen. This guy has transformed from a raw, inconsistent passer into a legitimate superstar. He's got a cannon for an arm and the athleticism to make plays with his legs. Here's why you might prefer Allen over Lamar:

  • Passing Volume: Allen is the focal point of the Bills' offense, and they love to throw the ball. He's consistently among the league leaders in passing attempts, which gives him a massive advantage in fantasy football. More pass attempts mean more opportunities for touchdowns and yardage, plain and simple.

  • Rushing Ability (Still Good!): While he might not be Lamar Jackson-level, Josh Allen is no slouch when it comes to running the ball. He regularly picks up valuable yardage and scores touchdowns with his legs. This adds a nice cushion to his fantasy score, and it makes him less reliant on his passing numbers alone.

  • Elite Weapons: Stefon Diggs, Gabe Davis, and Dalton Kincaid – need I say more? Allen has a stacked receiving corps that can make plays downfield. These guys are all capable of making big catches and scoring touchdowns, which directly benefits Allen's fantasy production.

  • Consistent Performance: Allen has been remarkably consistent over the past few seasons. He's a reliable source of fantasy points week in and week out, and he rarely has those complete dud performances that can sink your team. You know what you're getting with Allen, and that's a valuable asset in fantasy football.

Of course, Allen isn't without his drawbacks either. He can be prone to turnovers at times, and his reliance on his arm can lead to some boom-or-bust performances. But overall, he's one of the safest and most productive quarterbacks in fantasy football.

Head-to-Head Comparison

Okay, so we've made the case for both guys. Now, let's get down to the nitty-gritty and compare them directly:

  • Rushing Upside: Lamar wins hands down. His rushing ability is simply on another level compared to Allen.

  • Passing Volume: Allen takes the cake here. He throws the ball way more than Lamar, giving him more opportunities for fantasy points.

  • Weapons: This is close, but I'd give a slight edge to Allen. Diggs is a true WR1, and the Bills' receiving corps is incredibly deep.

  • Consistency: Allen is generally more consistent than Lamar, who can be prone to more volatile performances.

  • Injury Risk: Both quarterbacks carry some injury risk, but Lamar's playing style makes him slightly more susceptible to getting hurt.

Draft Strategy

So, who should you draft? Ultimately, it depends on your draft strategy and league settings. Here's a quick guide:

  • If you value rushing upside above all else: Go with Lamar Jackson. His rushing ability is unmatched, and it gives him a unique advantage in fantasy football.

  • If you prefer a more consistent and reliable performer: Josh Allen is your guy. He's a safe bet to put up big numbers week in and week out.

  • If you're playing in a PPR league: Allen's high passing volume gives him a slight edge.

  • If you're playing in a standard league: Lamar's rushing touchdowns become even more valuable.

Personally, I think it's close, and you can't really go wrong with either guy. It really comes down to your personal preference and how the draft is unfolding. If Lamar is available a round later than Allen, I'd probably snag him. But if Allen is still on the board when it's my turn, I wouldn't hesitate to pull the trigger.

The Bottom Line

Lamar Jackson and Josh Allen are both elite fantasy quarterbacks with the potential to lead your team to a championship. Consider your league settings, draft strategy, and personal preferences when making your decision. And remember, have fun with it! That's what fantasy football is all about.

So, there you have it, folks! The ultimate showdown between Lamar Jackson and Josh Allen. Who are you taking in your fantasy draft? Let me know in the comments below! Happy drafting, and may the odds be ever in your favor!